Portal's Aperture R&D: Can gaming and comedy work together?

by Paul Verhoeven Featured 7 Comments 24 Votes 2756 Views 21/03/2013 Back to Articles

Aperture R&D is a new webseries, chronicling the lives of the men and women (but mostly men, apparently) who work down in the underbelly of Aperture, the fictional company nesting at the sweaty, rotten core of the gaming masterpiece, Portal, and the superb sequel Portal 2.

It's hard, however, for me to discuss it. I know Aperture R&D is machinima, and I know that it's a labour of love from fans. And as a fan, I care deeply about the gooey, succulent marrow that lies within the bones of fan service; I want to suck it out, dammit. I just want to suck. It. Right. Out.

Grotesque imagery aside, often times machinima is cringe-worthy. It's less obvious when the machinima in question utilises in-game graphics; in these cases, it can be completely bonerifically excellent (look at Red Vs. Blue). But even fan films made using the graphics engines of the games being paid tribute to, there's typically one thing that falls flat.

As a fan, I care deeply about the gooey, succulent marrow that lies within the bones of fan service.

Comedy.

Now I'm not a comic genius by any means -- my schtick is, typically, me combining references to unicorns, erections, glitter and explosions, and hoping it somehow doesn't come out a complete mess. But I am also a paid performer, having done Melbourne International Comedy Festival, Perth Fringe and Adelaide Fringe runs for several years now, and I do my (incredibly middling and still evolving) comedy 'thing' on TV, too, so I'd like to think that I at least have a modicum of appreciation for when comedy hits, and when it doesn't.

Which might be why Aperture R&D chafes me so much. The sets are lovely, the amount of care poured into the project is awe inspiring, and the whole thing is polished. Polished with technical know-how I couldn't even begin to muster up myself.

But where it falls down is on the comedy front; it's funny (in my opinion) in the same way that a first year law review sketch is funny, in that it doesn't hit punchlines, and doesn't innovate. It's by no means bad, but this is Portal. Portal is a nuanced, subtle fusion of minimalist sci-fi and, vitally, properly concise and biting comedic timing.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.Watch episode 1 of Aperture R&D

The aim of the entirely subjective critique is not to dump on the guys at Wayside Creations. They've done a great job on so many levels here, they really have. The aim is, instead, to ask a question: can gaming and comedy work together?

On the one hand, there's this argument: gamers intake frightening amounts of games, all of which are filled with characters, events and place names. Gamers therefore enjoy comedy rife with references which, when it comes to actually making jokes about gaming, means the jokes themselves are nothing but references, meaning the material falls down when viewed through the lens of good comedy.

The other argument is that we're hitting a point where gaming and comedy are making sweet, noisy love, and giving birth to games like Borderlands 2, or the recent Citadel DLC for Mass Effect 3, both of which exhibit objectively warm, witty chunks of comedy goodness. And if this keeps happening, then maybe comedy will become something that gamers, game makers and machinima makers turn into a legitimate strength, rather than just a hobby they swat around lazily from time to time.

By Paul Verhoeven

Link to us http://pc.mmgn.com/Articles/aperture-r-d-can-gaming-and-comedy-work
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Portal 2

Portal 2 Portal 2 Portal 2 Portal 2 Portal 2 Portal 2 Portal 2
Game Profile: Portal 2
Portal 2 Australian Release: Out Now

Portal's Aperture R&D: Can gaming and comedy work together? Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
I loved it.. Watched it a few days ago actually..
I find some fan videos pretty funny, but not really series, more one-offs.
...this isnt what i was thinking when i read the title...

didnt find the video too amusing -_-
Paul Verhoeven, Patch Kolan...

This new games fix hookup is pretty good for mmgn

I just want to suck. It



That's what she said [MOG]
Who? Your mother?

:P
en.wikipedia.org/... - Games can be bloody hilarious. Nuff said. (This video sucks ass though)

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2
  • Portal 2Portal 2 Video
  • Portal 2Portal 2 Video
  • Portal 2Portal 2 Video

Recently Read

Featured PC Content

Most Anticipated June Game

Most Anticipated June Game

22 hours ago Polls 2 4
Windows 10 will be released globally on July 29

Windows 10 will be released globally on July 29

Gryllis 1 hour News 1 4
The most embarrassing E3 moments ever

The most embarrassing E3 moments ever

Tano 3 hours Articles 8 9
XCOM 2 revealed, coming exclusively to PC this November
Tano 4 hours News 1 2
Big games of June

Big games of June

Tano 22 hours Articles 9 5
Advent teaser site points to new XCOM

Advent teaser site points to new XCOM

Tano 23 hours News 0 2
Del Toro throws support behind Silent Hills petition

Del Toro throws support behind Silent Hills petition

Tano 1 day News 5 4
The Friendly Fire Show delayed (until E3)

The Friendly Fire Show delayed (until E3)

Podcast 1 day Articles 0 2

Community Content

Wii U - 2, MMGN - 0

Wii U - 2, MMGN - 0

01/05/2015 Blog 14 1

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Windows 10 will be released globally on July 29

maxiboy 28 mins ago
Username

MicDaMan is now Level 28!

MicDaMan 48 mins ago
Username

commented on FIFA 16 introduces Women’s National Teams

Gryllis 1 day ago
Username

Mickyt888, punk commented on FIFA 16 introduces Women’s National Teams

Mickyt888 1 day ago
Username

Pilkingbod, Olly commented on Shocking new Hatred gameplay trailer reveals release date (NSFW)

Pilkingbod 1 day ago
Username

xrgbfanboi is now Level 2!

xrgbfanboi 2 days ago