Member Submitted

Colossal review #1: Terraria vs Minecraft

by tails

6 Comments 17 Votes 2592 Views 15/12/2011 Back to Reviews

Terraria - 10 / 10

Colossal review #1: Terraria vs Minecraft

Intro

Alrighty, lets get this intro going. first of all, before the S@$!-storm takes place; both games are competely different i know, out of all honesty i am a terraria fan but was a minecraft fan too at some stage in my life so i can understand the hatred, and lastly this isn’t a piece of troll material i just thought it'd be a 'cool' idea to mash each game up into one review for their similar environments they offer within each others game, respectively.

Gameplay

/Minecraft

my first interaction with minecraft was mind blowing, my mate had the game the day it was released to the public (beta, or alpha, one of those two) he told me to come around and check out this new game he’s got. Me, not expecting anything saw the first 10 minutes of this game and I was astonished;
“HOLY BRO, you just made a table from that wood you got from that tree you fisted to death”
“WHAA THAA FAAAQ, you made a autism fort, from the supplies you gathered?!”
and so forth I managed to become more and more amazed on... (no sexual innuendoes intended in the above quotes)



after my few 20mins of gameplay to myself, I thought; if this is where the gaming industry is going with indie developers, ill definitely be buying more of these types of games rather than the stuff we see on shelves that are all dream shattering and hope murderers.

Its so simple how the world of minecraft works. You start off with nothing, you find resources from the environment around you, use those resources to defend yourself and build up the courage to gain a further progress in the game like finding dungeons, rare resources, defeat bosses. But even after all of that, the game is endless and offers unbelievable playtime value, see the thing is with this game; YOU DONT HAVE TO DO ALL OF THAT! (caps intended) its up to you in this free-wondering universe to do as you want, build what you want, and progress how ever you intend too! As a 90's kid and gamer at a casual/hardcore standing this game is what will appeal to people like me and you, for many reasons;
-retro aesthetic
-basic gameplay
-16-bit sound (or similar too)
-and none of this how to play tutorial crap we are flooded with in today’s games

/Terraria

So after many months of the minecraft phase there was a month were I had nothing I really wanted to play, you know those days. Where you constantly flick up and down through your games list on steam, or windows menus, or legally downloaded free games folder (no-one does the last option...). Whilst flicking through my steam library and being utterly bored to death, I decided to check the release of new games, and this made me stumble across terraria.



Before I actually got the game, I actually did a lot of research into the game before actually purchasing it the week after, I watch the developer redigit and his friend Blue play through the game together, starting out from scratch. I thought this was awesome already that the developer was playing his own game, pointing out faults in his own game, and generally mucking about with his friend, whilst uploading a 'lets play' to youtube. It really is a good way to know who and what type of person made the game you are playing.
Terraria is very different to minecraft, but has a similar aesthetic when it comes to environment and crafting to a certain extent. The game is set as a plateformer played in a 2D world, that is randomly generated like minecraft. There are different biomes (environments), enemies, and tiers which the player must overcome using the help of resources, npc's, and crafting. The tiers in terraria really is what sets it apart, and makes progression a really fluent way of pushing the player, to build courage up to face certain environments, enemies and bosses that couldn’t be achieved at early stages of the game. As confusing as that whole paragraph sounds, its how ive managed to read and see upon many hours of playing.



Presentation & Sound

as much as I would like to add to this part of the review, they both respectively present each other as something that cannot be compared to the mainstream games have to offer. The uniqueness terraria & minecraft have I find cannot be argued upon or criticise, they are their own sub-genre of games.

Overall Conclusion

As the Final clash between the two, I found the updates that minecraft offer are a massive pain in the arse, most of which are petty and useless little constant updates that are of irrelevance and mostly seem to be have been directly ported from mods the community outside the developing team had made, which overall feels slack and as everybody now knows of Notch its not unexpected from mojang. 'Redigit' (developer) as ive got to know is a Bro, he wants hardcore gaming but want to please all audiences, with casual pleasing (for those that don’t want to play 'hardcore'), and little other gaming aspects hes managed to easter egg'd (sort of) into the game, eg; my character is dressed as Link form the legend of zelda series, you can obtain a fireflower as a weapon like super mario bros fireflower, light disc from the movie tron acts similar to like it would off the movie, etc... although this is good, it does ruin what it has to offer, which is the unobtainable uniqueness, and I can safely say that for minecraft and terraria.



In the end its all how about each one of us feels more enjoyable from minecraft or terraria, and that’s what we play these games for, because they are endless fun and the re-play value only seems to continue. Both games are not finished as well, which really makes as wonder how each game will turn in final development.

I would give a scoring for each game, but ill leave that to you guys.

Please rate or comment if you liked this review! Cheers!

by Tails



Terraria Review

10
Platform: PS3 / Xbox / PC
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Terraria

Terraria Terraria Terraria Josh's Competition Entry
Game Profile: Terraria
Terraria Australian Release: Out now

Colossal review #1: Terraria vs Minecraft Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
nice review.. it's good o know a bit about both games that are simular to each other.. :)

M@ndyz said: nice review.. it's good o know a bit about both games that are simular to each other..


Thanks mankyz :)
Appreciate the feedback :D
Minecraft Alpha (love)

kiryuu said: Minecraft Alpha


That feel.
We all miss.
they are both good games... i guess its just the dimension that make a difference - 3D or 2D

DEXcrafter said: they are both good games... i guess its just the dimension that make a difference - 3D or 2D


a lot more than that, but i guess you could count that.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Terraria
  • Terraria
  • Terraria
  • Josh's Competition Entry
  • TerrariaTerraria Video
  • TerrariaTerraria Video

Recently Read

Featured PC Content

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

27/03/2014 Polls 8 13
Publishers and tickets confirmed for EB Expo 2014
Gryllis 7 hours News 2 4
Fox News implicates Dark Souls in murder

Fox News implicates Dark Souls in murder

Tano 12 hours News 6 5
Destiny, Halo composer fired from Bungie ''without cause''

Destiny, Halo composer fired from Bungie ''without cause''

Gryllis 1 day News 0 6
Snoop Dogg to narrate Call of Duty: Ghosts, for realz

Snoop Dogg to narrate Call of Duty: Ghosts, for realz

Tano 1 day News 7 6
Tomb Raider 2 gameplay details surface

Tomb Raider 2 gameplay details surface

Tano 1 day News 3 3
Pretend to be a plane in Cult Of The Wind

Pretend to be a plane in Cult Of The Wind

Tano 1 day News 2 6
Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Review

Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Review

Harry 1 day Reviews 1 7
The Elder Scrolls Online review: Entering the PvP war
Jayden27 2 days Articles 2 8

Community Content

A loser's review of FIFA 14
03/03/2014 Blog 11 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Minecraft PS3 Edition set for retail disc release

M@ndyz 1 hour ago
Username

sjt333, Pact, Booth commented on Classic Fox News: 'Video type things', Dark Souls implicated in murder

sjt333 1 hour ago
Username

commented on Publishers and tickets confirmed for EB Expo 2014

maxiboy 7 hours ago
Username

Gryllis, Tano commented on 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

Gryllis 7 hours ago
Username

commented on Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Review

xxDrexlxx 8 hours ago
Username

MicDaMan is now Level 27!

MicDaMan 8 hours ago
Username

Gryllis, M@ndyz commented on Minecraft PS3 Edition set for retail disc release

Gryllis 9 hours ago
Username

SlappyWag, Tano, J053pH commented on Classic Fox News: 'Video type things', Dark Souls implicated in murder

SlappyWag 12 hours ago
Username

Silence, CybaCowboy commented on Sony's Shuhei Yoshida banned on Miiverse

Silence 23 hours ago
Username

DarkJibTEC, Toki commented on Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru to get a second season

DarkJibTEC 1 day ago