Minecraft Review

by Harry Hughes Featured

19 Comments 28 Votes 3923 Views 25/11/2011 Back to Reviews

It has been around for over two years and has been the primary source of attention for thousands of gamers and critics alike, yet Minecraft seems to be one of the hardest titles to review for analysts, given the game’s unique structure and status as a religion more-so than as a game. Minecraft is one of the very few true sandbox games around; any creative boundaries are because of the player, not the game. It has spawned its own genre and inspired developers to think about the replayability of their titles. It is fair to say Minecraft has been the most influential indie game of all time.

It is also fair to say, however, that this sandbox/mining/building/adventure mash-up is not for everyone. It may be easy to lose hours in building a 1:1 replica of your favourite spaceship, but doing so requires a lot of motivation and hard work, which somewhat defeats the purpose of a video game. Sure, it’s possible to wind down, relax and explore in Minecraft, but that’s not what thrusts Minecraft into the arms of critical acclaim.

In fact, just what did put Minecraft at the top of every gamer’s wish-list is hard to pin-point, because there is just so much going for this magnificent title. Perhaps the most appealing aspect of the title is that you get out of it what you put in. This makes for a highly rewarding experience, despite the shortcomings presented by the game’s mind-boggling journey to the endgame.

What Minecraft Got Right

Throws players into the deep end - Starting up a new Minecraft world will simply put you in a random area, with no instruction on what to do. While this may seem like a negative, it forces players to learn their way around the game. Many will no-doubt jump to online guides and resources, but those who learn the ropes from scratch are given an even more highly-rewarding experience.

Minecraft

No literal boundaries - Quite simply, you get out of Minecraft whatever you put into it. There are no boundaries - worlds go on infinitely. As a player you have the ability to collect hundreds of different resources and put them towards any type of building you desire. The more creative a player is, the better their results, and this is vital to the success of a sandbox/building game.

Great world generation - Some buggy world generation was cause for concern during some stages of the beta, but the team at Mojang has really lifted its game and provided a procedural generation system capable of impressing gamers and programmers alike. Ravines, mountains, rivers, villages, strongholds and more combine to provide players with some incredible views which easily impress, despite this title’s “blocky” visual style.

Plenty to customise - While the “true mod support” we were promised for the game’s release has not yet been given to us, the ability to use mods is not lost. Almost any idea you could think of has already been implemented through a user mod, so players can potentially add an incredible amount of variation to Minecraft’s already-versatile engine. In addition to this, users have the ability to completely overhaul the game’s visuals if they desire; every single aspect of the visuals or gameplay can be changed.

Minecraft

Fitting sound - Somehow, the repetitive sounds of breaking and placing blocks does not become an annoyance. That in itself is an achievement. However, if you take into account the relaxing-yet-vibrant soundtrack and the memorable moans and grunts of monsters, it’s not hard to see that the sound in Minecraft does its job flawlessly.

Solid online - The online platform in Minecraft allows for the ultimate group projects. The ability to work together with several people at once on the one building makes Minecraft a social experience, pending you take your creativity online.

Caters to both casual and core crowds - Minecraft might at first seem like a game made for casual crowds, but switching a few options around makes it anything but. For those who are just beginning to dip their toes in the gaming world with Minecraft, “Peaceful” mode stops any horrid creatures from spawning, and “Creative” mode allows unlimited use of any type of block the player desires. On the flip side, core gamers might like to switch the difficulty to “Hard”, meaning limited resources, more enemies and damage. Beyond this, the insanely hardcore can turn on an aptly named “hardcore” mode, meaning that just one death will end the whole in-game world -- and any hard work which went into it.

What Minecraft Got Wrong

The ‘adventure’ doesn’t work - Now that we have a full-release, we have a full game. That is, one with a ‘story’ of sorts. However, the adventure which leads up to the end-game is confusing and doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. The NPC villagers around each world do not aid the user in progressing to The End, so many may not even be aware of what is a brilliant and epic final battle.

Minecraft

No proper mod support (yet) - Sure, it might still be in the works, but this is a feature players were promised upon the full release. Conflicting mods can cause the game to not run and are therefore a major annoyance to some players who wish to tweak their experience.

The Final Verdict

The story of Minecraft is inspirational. What we have today is the result of two years of hard work from a team that once consisted of just one man. Yet somehow, almost every aspect of play has been accounted for and executed brilliantly, time and again. Every element of this title fits the next beautifully, and things are only going to get better: while we may have seen the full release of Minecraft, we certainly haven’t seen the end of it.

By Harry Hughes.

Minecraft

Platform: Xbox / PC / PS4
Developer: Mojang
Similar to: Terraria
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

More Info on Minecraft

Minecraft Minecraft Minecraft Minecraft Minecraft Minecraft Minecraft
Game Profile: Minecraft
Minecraft Australian Release: Out Now

Minecraft Review Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
I'm curious as to wonder where the missing .4 is...
I might actually have to play this some time [Shifty]

How much is the full version?
27 bucks
Wait... There's a "The End" ?

I want it!
minecraft is like a drug... sooo addictive

Doles said: Wait... There's a "The End" ?
I want it!


Its in the game by default but you have to do this whole thing.. Lol

Harry said: 27 bucks



Serious?
Sheesh, glad I bought it at the end of Alpha. $15, and every up date from hereon I get for free when Beta purchasers still have to pay. :D

Dénor said:

Harry said: 27 bucks


Serious?
Sheesh, glad I bought it at the end of Alpha. $15, and every up date from hereon I get for free when Beta purchasers still have to pay.


I got it for $10 i think. Great deal!!
I don't agree with 10 for sound or graphics. The sound effects are a little irritating and the animals only have about 3 sounds. The graphics are charming in a way but still bad and meant for lower rigs. Mojang should have included additional Higher def texture picks and easy ways to swap between them. I agree with everything else

Doles said: Wait... There's a "The End" ?
I want it!


I found an "end portal" on the new map, we just need to activate it.
also the land generation is hideous. It was much better before

Marge said: also the land generation is hideous. It was much better before


All my maps have been stunning. Never seen a thing out of place since like alpha 1.3 or something
Where does the 9.6 come from? I've never played this game, nor will I in the future (probably) but from the 4 individual aspect scores you gave the game the overall score would warrant a 9.9 taken as an average. How is the overall score calculated?

Skrable said: Where does the 9.6 come from? I've never played this game, nor will I in the future (probably) but from the 4 individual aspect scores you gave the game the overall score would warrant a 9.9 taken as an average. How is the overall score calculated?


We don't use averages -- it doesn't really give an accurate reading of how good the game is. Consider a game with the most beastly graphics ever, an amazing soundtrack, which cost only $2.. if the controls don't even work one bit, the game isn't good overall, is it? Even given the great visuals and sound.

I felt that as an 'adventure', the journey to 'The End' was very disappointing (other than the boss fight) and did little to add to the experience. Poor implementation can mean lost time for players who want to keep building -- was it really worth adding in the end anyway?

In fairness, this is what players wanted, and Minecraft is hardly a game which needs an adventure mode, but nevertheless, it left a sour taste in my mouth.
Excellent review Harry :)

Skarteh said: Excellent review Harry


Cheers Skart!
I love Minecraft. Nice review. :)
nice review =D
I agree with the review :D

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • Minecraft
  • MinecraftMinecraft Video
  • MinecraftMinecraft Video
  • MinecraftMinecraft Video

Recently Read

Featured PC Content

Games of October: Your most wanted

Games of October: Your most wanted

06/10/2014 Polls 9 16
3D Realms returns with an epic 32-game retro anthology

3D Realms returns with an epic 32-game retro anthology

Tano 12 hours News 4 3
Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

maxiboy 21 hours News 3 4
World of Warcraft to get local Australian, NZ servers

World of Warcraft to get local Australian, NZ servers

Tano 1 day News 1 7
GTA: San Andreas 10th Anniversary - A look back

GTA: San Andreas 10th Anniversary - A look back

Tano 1 day Articles 9 10
Property developer caught out using SimCity screenshots

Property developer caught out using SimCity screenshots

Tano 1 day News 1 8
The Evil Within Essential Survival Tips

The Evil Within Essential Survival Tips

Gryllis 1 day Articles 2 4
Shadow of Mordor is a must buy: Here’s why

Shadow of Mordor is a must buy: Here’s why

Tano 2 days Articles 8 11
Gyromanic: I played 3 hours of Far Cry 4, but ignored story

Gyromanic: I played 3 hours of Far Cry 4, but ignored story

Gryllis 2 days Articles 3 9

Community Content

Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

maxiboy 21 hours News 3 4
Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

Awesome Gaming Stuff Of Tomorrow, Today! Vol. 3

02/09/2014 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

kangle4, MrMoo, Tano, KezDaMuss commented on 3D Realms returns with an epic 32-game retro anthology

kangle4 6 hours ago
Username

Pilkingbod, Tano, Mobe1969 commented on Some 10 years on, San Andreas’ Grove Street is still home

Pilkingbod 6 hours ago
Username

punk, A2ra3l, Tano commented on Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

punk 9 hours ago
Username

Tano, Brutus commented on Some 10 years on, San Andreas’ Grove Street is still home

Tano 15 hours ago
Username

maxiboy's news - Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down has been featured by Guyver, great job!

Guyver 15 hours ago
Username

maxiboy's news - Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down has been featured by Guyver, great job!

Guyver 15 hours ago
Username

maxiboy posted a news - Dev threatens Gaben and gets game taken down

maxiboy 21 hours ago