Sword & Sworcery PC Review: Lunar Phases And Clunky Controls

by Stephen Heller Featured

3 Comments 11 Votes 2835 Views 15/05/2012 Back to Reviews

Lunar phases and clunky controls let this adventure fall.

When Superbrothers: Sword & Sworcery EP arrived on the iPad over a year ago, it delivered a stunning experience that still stands out today as a triumph for the device. News that this point-and-click adventure was coming to PC excited fans of the genre, and while it still delivers all the things we love, does it improve on what the iOS version started?

What Sword & Sworcery Got Right

Strange story that is compelling - Sword & Sworcery is weird. You take control of Scythian; an adventurer who is wandering a luscious forest realm. The story is drip fed to the player via some well written text boxes that appear through dialogue or examination of interesting elements. There is also a classy self-aware narrator who smokes a pipe and helps inch the story along, yet the game is never blatantly obvious and continues to play its cards close to it's chest.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Check out the official trailer!

Visual and audio delight - The graphical throwback to 8-bit visuals is nothing short but stunning. The developers have managed to throw in some absolutely jaw-dropping lighting effects and some seriously fluid animations to make Sword & Sworcery easily one of the best looking pixel games of late. The attention to detail really makes the art stand out, and the quest feel more alive.

When you add that to the amazing soundtrack you have a deadly combination on your hands. The soundtrack is full of chip tunes mixed with hints of strings and modern synths to add more substance and make the game feel epic. Each action brings with it a gorgeous sound, and before long you will be poking and prodding just to hear what sound is going to be played. This is definitely a title you need a good set of headphones for.

Unique lunar phase mechanic- Sword & Sworcery employs an utterly unique concept using the lunar phase to dictate gameplay. Without spoiling the quest for you, there are sections of the game that can only be played and completed during certain phases of the lunar cycle. It's strange, and we're not sure why it exists, but it helps the game stand out.

What Sword & Sworcery Got Wrong

Feels like a rushed port - There's nothing worse than getting a rushed PC port of a AAA title on release day, but it hurts even more when Sword & Sworcey feels like a rushed port almost a year after the first release on iOS. The tutorial messages of "tap and hold here" are easy enough to forgive, but the control scheme itself still feels very touch-based, yet this time with a mouse. It feels clunky and is a little frustrating at times, and it definitely hurts the experience. If you have an option to play Sword & Sworcery on an iPad, definitely go with that version just for controls alone.

Lunar mechanic breaks interest - The very mechanic that makes Sword & Sworcery so unique is ultimately its downfall. Relying on the the lunar phase to complete sections of the game is intriguing, but it completely destroys the flow of the adventure. Waiting 4 days to finish the next section of the game seemed to suit the iOS version, you often found yourself playing while you were out and about in short bursts. However when sitting down at a PC to enjoy the experience, it seems like an unnecessary chore. Of course you can always cheat and change the date on your computer, but even that is a minor inconvenience.

The Final Verdict

Gorgeous from start to finish, Superbrothers: Sword & Sworcery EP is a paragon title for what developers and powerful iOS devices are capable of. Unfortunately that prowess seems to be lost in translation in this sub-par PC port, that suffers from clunky controls and feels rather rushed. Very rarely do we see audio, visual and unique design fit together in a seemingly perfect experience, and we think everyone should experience what this unique adventure has to offer. Having said that, if you have an iPad, we'd suggest picking up that version.

By Stephen Heller - Bio

Superbrothers Sword & Sworcery EP

Platform: PC
Similar to: Machinarium
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

Sword & Sworcery PC Review: Lunar Phases And Clunky Controls Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
okay, very inaccurate review, the lunar phases technically have nothing to do with the game, it can be completed in one day, to 100%, you simply need to defeat a certain dancing boar (you dont have to execute him, and if you want 100% you have to let him live), collect his key, go to a certain room and sit down, and it'll cycle the phases of the moon, the next time you're in the dream world, it'll be that phase.

thoraxe said: okay, very inaccurate review, the lunar phases technically have nothing to do with the game, it can be completed in one day, to 100%, you simply need to defeat a certain dancing boar (you dont have to execute him, and if you want 100% you have to let him live), collect his key, go to a certain room and sit down, and it'll cycle the phases of the moon, the next time you're in the dream world, it'll be that phase.


I've done all those steps on my own, but I'm in the dream world right now waiting for the next moon cycle.

I highly recommend it though; it breaks off from what makes a game a "game", but it's a refreshing experience. My only quibble with the game is its spare save points, but then again it's meant for a smartphone where the game saves your state automatically. [MOG]

thoraxe said: you simply need to defeat a certain dancing boar (you dont have to execute him, and if you want 100% you have to let him live)


Hm, I've actually managed to get 100% score with killing boor, and even without getting #moar achievement.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook

Recently Read

Featured PC Content

Most anticipated game of 2015

Most anticipated game of 2015

08/01/2015 Polls 12 15
Battlefield Hardline beta kicks off February 3
Tano 2 days News 3 4
More than 3.3 billion goals have been scored in FIFA

More than 3.3 billion goals have been scored in FIFA

Tano 2 days News 0 6
Life is Strange launches with a dev diary
Gryllis 2 days News 1 4
Aussie hit TownCraft heading to PC in February
Gryllis 2 days News 0 3
Bartronica is Melbourne's newest video game bar

Bartronica is Melbourne's newest video game bar

Tano 3 days News 9 5
Wargaming eSports director Mohamed Fadl interview

Wargaming eSports director Mohamed Fadl interview

Tano 3 days Articles 0 1
This Is The Police could be the Breaking Bad of tycoon games

This Is The Police could be the Breaking Bad of tycoon games

Tano 3 days News 1 3
The Witcher 3 preview: Hands on with 2015's biggest RPG

The Witcher 3 preview: Hands on with 2015's biggest RPG

Gryllis 4 days Articles 9 6

Community Content

Top 5 Survival Games

Top 5 Survival Games

Zinker 6 days Articles 0 4
Work Experience at The MMGN Office

Work Experience at The MMGN Office

12/01/2015 Blog 10 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Mirage's super nendoroid collection image dump

zurczner 8 hours ago
Username

K4ZMA made a change to JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders

K4ZMA 14 hours ago
Username

kangle4, DarkJibTEC commented on Mirage's super nendoroid collection image dump

kangle4 16 hours ago
Username

commented on 5 Things I’d like from future Pokémon games

sjt333 23 hours ago
Username

Blak, K4ZMA, Zinker and other 2 users commented on Mirage's super nendoroid collection image dump

Blak 1 day ago
Username

commented on Battlefield Hardline beta kicks off February 3

Zinker 1 day ago
Username

Zinker shared a story - There is something about survival

Zinker 2 days ago
Username

Blob, Armige, K4ZMA and other 2 users commented on 5 Things I’d like from future Pokémon games

Blob 2 days ago
Username

commented on The Mario timeline in chronological order

MoeMan 2 days ago