Deponia Review - Trash or Treasure?

by Stephen Heller Featured

2 Comments 10 Votes 1509 Views 07/09/2012 Back to Reviews

A trash-filled adventure that misses the mark

What Deponia Got Right
  • + Colourful art style is inviting
  • + Some sections are genuinely funny
  • + Heartwarming story
What Deponia Got Wrong
  • - Relies too much on hit & miss comedy
  • - Doesn't bring anything new to the table
  • - First act drags on for too long
  • - Some puzzles defy all logic

 

It's a good time to be an adventure gamer. After years of struggling after the reported death of the genre at the end of the 1990s, indie developers have brought the lifeless corpse back to life, delivering dozens of new adventures every year. Deponia is the latest point-and-click adventure to come across my desk, and while it does a number of things right, it fails to hit the mark, held back by a reliance on hit and miss humour and puzzles that defy the rules of logic.

Get the Adobe Flash Player to see this video.

Check out the official trailer!

Meet Rufus; a misguided layabout who seems like a living clone of Guybrush Threepwood yet is nowhere near as funny nor as likeable. His attempts at offering up a whimsical retort to each and EVERY line of dialogue often hit the mark, leaving the comedy feel forced and overdone. However when he does land a good joke, he can be quite hilarious, yet after spending more than a few hours with him, you'll be happy to see the end of the game.

The central story here is that Rufus lives on the trash-filled planet of Deponia, and in an attempt to leave his excess baggage and smelly home behind, he gets caught up in scandalous tale involving the rich and entitled. It's up to our hero to save the day with the help of his friends, creating a heartwarming scenario that actually touches on some important issues in today's society with our excessive trash problems.

The first act of the game certainly sets up the foundation for what becomes an interesting story, but it simply drags on for far too long and paints Rufus in a negative light.

My major gripe with Deponia lies within the puzzles. While some of them can be solved without breaking a sweat, however a good portion of them defy all means of logical thinking. While cast members will often give you hints that will tell you how to combine two completely ridiculous items together to create a solution, the fact is you shouldn't need to rely on them to solve your problems. When you absolutely must ask a NPC in order to solve a problem it ceases to be a hint.

The first act of the game certainly sets up the foundation for what becomes an interesting story, but it simply drags on for far too long and paints Rufus in a negative light. Once you make it to the city hub things get a little more bearable, and the game really picks up steam towards the end, but by then it's too late to really count.

When it comes to presentation, Deponia is one of the better looking adventures we've seen this year. Bright and colourful graphics pop from the screen, providing highly detailed characters and environments that go a long way to making this game worthwhile. The impressive soundtrack is quirky and original, and will surely please gamers who like something different.

Despite the fact that Rufus seems to try too hard at times, his supporting cast often provide some of the most hilarious lines throughout the adventure. The obvious tension at the beginning of the game between Rufus and his ex-girlfriend Toni will hit home for those who dated a psychopath in their past and Wenzel's constant snide remarks hit their mark almost every time.

That is why it is so disappointing to see Deponia fall short of it's true potential. It doesn't bring anything new to the table, sticking to the conventions of classics such as The Secret of Monkey Island or Full Throttle, yet it doesn't pull it off with as much style or panache, which is sad considering those games are over a decade old.

The Final Verdict

Deponia is a great looking game with a lot of potential, but it falls short thanks to a series of puzzles that defy logic. Rufus is a strong character, but his hit and miss comedy retorts are far too frequent, and he comes off forced as a result. Perhaps something was lost in translation (the game was originally in German), however it still offers enough to make it notable for lovers of point and click adventures. Wait for a sale and you'll find something to like amongst the trash.

By Stephen Heller

Deponia

Platform: PC
Developer: Daedelic Entertainment
Similar to: The Secret of Monkey Island, Full Throttle
 
Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

Deponia Review - Trash or Treasure? Comments

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
Awww sorry to hear it failed to hit the mark! I'd still play it, just because I love AG's.
Yeah don't get me wrong it is a pretty fun adventure but it could have been great instead of just pretty good.

Post a comment

Leave a comment Log in with Facebook
  • DeponiaDeponia Video

Recently Read

Featured PC Content

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

Games of April: Your Most Anticipated?

27/03/2014 Polls 8 14
IRL Shooter is returning to Melbourne

IRL Shooter is returning to Melbourne

MezFunky 4 hours Articles 0 3
LEGO The Hobbit review

LEGO The Hobbit review

Tano 7 hours Reviews 0 3
Has most of E3 2014 been leaked already?

Has most of E3 2014 been leaked already?

Gryllis 7 hours Articles 2 7
Fatal Frame movie in the works
Tano 8 hours News 2 2
WWII shooter Red Orchestra 2 is free right now

WWII shooter Red Orchestra 2 is free right now

Tano 8 hours News 0 1
Will there be a new Prince of Persia at E3?

Will there be a new Prince of Persia at E3?

Gryllis 12 hours News 0 2
Watch Dogs PS4 footage

Watch Dogs PS4 footage

Tano 12 hours News 3 5

Community Content

A loser's review of FIFA 14
03/03/2014 Blog 13 0

MMGN Updates

Status
Updating..
Username

commented on Fatal Frame movie in the works

taxidermy 14 mins ago
Username

commented on 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil review

sjt333 32 mins ago
Username

commented on Anime.MMGN's 2nd Anniversary

xxSoS 1 hour ago
Username

tsubibo, inubazh11 commented on Zuckerberg tried Sony's Project Morpheus VR before Facebook bought Oculus

tsubibo 1 hour ago
Username

commented on New Ace Attorney goes back in time without Phoenix Wright

CptAwesome 2 hours ago
Username

Elraro, MX_Xizz0R commented on First image confirms new Call of Duty has a man in it

Elraro 5 hours ago
Username

commented on Fatal Frame movie in the works

zurczner 6 hours ago
Username

Tano, MX_Xizz0R commented on Introducing H1Z1: Sony’s zombie apocalypse fantasy game

Tano 7 hours ago
Username

MX_Xizz0R, Elraro commented on Zuckerberg tried Sony's Project Morpheus VR before Facebook bought Oculus

MX_Xizz0R 8 hours ago